Political
Footnotes
By
Stuart James
IPS Features


Return to Current IPS Features

Return to Catalogue

IPS Features Staff

International Press Service

 







BUSH=S TAX CUT: A RETURN TO DEFICIT SPENDING

 The President is proposing a deep tax cut wile, at the same time, proposing substantial increases in federal spending thereby increasing the deficit.  The President=s tax cut will create a record deficit. 

With the President=s plan creating a record deficit, the American public must ask whether President Bush=s tax cut is sound economic policy or a Apolitical gimmick.”  The American public must ask whether the President=s deficit-producing plan is a plan that will continue to sink the Federal Government into debt. 

In order to provide a stimulus package for economic growth, the President should take action to reduce the deficit, balance the budget and restructure our tax system.  In doing so, President Bush should consider:

1.  In many states, like Tennessee, the primary source of state revenue is the sales tax. Why isn’t the President suggesting that the sales tax become a deduction on our federal taxes?  In order to provide us with a plan for economic growth, the plan cannot simply call for a tax cut, it must call for true tax reform—tax reform including innovative ideas like making the sales tax deductible in certain situations. 

2.  Fuel taxes.  Between federal and state taxes on gasoline, we pay almost 37 cents a gallon for gas.  The President=s tax cut plan does not address reducing the gas tax or revamping the gas tax making gas more affordable for Americans.  Moreover, what about making the payment of state gas taxes deductible on our federal income tax return?

3.  Small-business owners pay a self-employment tax.  The President=s plan does not address the self-employment tax or any reduction in the self-employment tax to lighten the burden on a small-business person.

4. What about making other state and local taxes deductible on the federal income tax?  Many businesses in many states must pay a state franchise and excise tax.  Moreover, professionals in states like Tennessee must pay a professional privilege tax.  Many local governments include city personal property taxes and county taxes. 

6. What about property taxes? 

In order to have sound economic plan to help people reinvest money into the economy, the President should propose a plan that includes deducting certain state and local taxes on our returns and giving us an opportunity to save money and reinvest it into the economy.

The President=s plan is not for tax reform.  It is a tax cut, a simple fix that will cause the budget deficit to grow.  The plan is not comprehensive.

In order to stimulate the economy the President must realize that real tax reform means changes in the system to provide us with incentives to invest in the economy.  The President must also present a realistic budget, wisely using tax dollars to provide valuable services to the public.  The budget should eliminate deficit spending. 

Unfortunately, the President’s plan does not restructure our system.  It is a plan that returns government to the deficit spending of the past.

It is time for our leaders to move beyond the political “tax cut” gimmicks.  If this President wishes to stimulate the economy, he should:

1.  Propose meaningful long-term tax reform, restructure the federal income tax system to lighten the tax burden, and examine new ways to provide meaningful deductions for those who pay a wide variety of state and local taxes.

 

2.  Propose a balanced budget.  The President cannot ignore the growing deficit.  If the President plans a short-term deficit to fund the war on Iraq, the President should honestly tell the American public that tax cuts would have to wait until we deal with the current crisis in Iraq.  The President, however, is taking the opposite approach—offering a politically popular tax cut while sinking our government deeper into debt.

Meaningful tax reform is not easy.  It becomes more difficult as the threat of war becomes real.  Unfortunately, our President is caught up in a political gimmick designed to increase poll numbers.  Until this President gets beyond the politics of Atax cuts@ and gets down to the real economic management of our government, deficits will grow and the economy will stagnate.  Returning us to the deficit spending of the past is a serious mistake; a mistake that will cost us more than this tax cut will give.

This President, however, has not learned from the mistakes of the past.