Political
Footnotes
by
Stuart James


Return to Current IPS Features

Return to Catalogue

IPS Features Staff

International Press Service

 






The Texas Legislature

For 119 years, Democrats controlled the Texas Legislature. For 119 years, the Republican Party was the minority party. Now the shoe is on the other foot, for the first time Republicans control the Texas Legislature.

This month, the nasty issue of redistricting came up in the State of Texas. The Republicans were set to ramrod a plan through the House, using their newfound control to advance the agenda of Tom Delay and the Republican Party. The issue turned so nasty that the Democrats knew they did not have the votes to stop the Republican plan. If the legislature continued with its business, the Republicans, for the first time in 119 years, would redistrict the state giving Republicans an advantage--giving the Republican Party an opportunity to elect Republicans over Democrats.

Doomed to failure, the Democrats bolted, they left Texas for Okalahoma. By leaving, the Democrats crippled the legislature—without the Democrats, the legislature lacked a quorum and could not do its business. The Democrats stayed away long enough causing the republican redistricting plan to die for want of legislative action.

In response, the Republican leaders dispatched the Texas Rangers. The Republican leadership gave the Rangers direction to find, and forcefully return, the Democrats. “The Republican Texas Ranger Recoupment Plan” was designed to recover those wayward Democrats, forcing them back so Republicans could push their plan through the legislature.

Of course, the Texas Ranger plan failed. The Texas Rangers could not cross state lines, go to Okalahoma and retrieve the AWOL Democrats. Eventually, just after the deadline to take action on redistricting passed, the wayward Democrats boarded a bus, and returned home. Victorious in their return, the Democrats knew their revolution defeated the Republican plan.

The redistricting plan proposed by Republicans would cost the Democrats five house seats. The plan proposed by Republicans was spearheaded by the Majority Leader of the US House of Representatives—US Representative Tom Delay (a Texas Republican). A conservative, Congressman Delay saw an opportunity to change the political landscape in his home state. What Congressman Delay did not see was the Democratic Defection—a defection derailing the Delay plan.

The Democrats, while in exile, stayed at a Holiday Inn in Okalahoma, ate at Denny’s and used their cell phones by the pool to take calls. Upon their return, some voters held up signs saying “welcome home heroes.” “We’ve weathered some troopers, we've weathered a tornado, and we weathered Denny's," said Representative Jim Dunnam, the group's leader. "No matter what happens, democracy won."

Did Democracy win?

The Republicans were not interested in compromise, they were not interested in fairness, and they were not interested in the Democratic view on the redistricting issue. The Republicans wanted Republicans in office. Republicans were wrong. The Democratic Defection showed they were wrong.

But what about the Democrats? Was their defection a stand for Democracy, or was it a realization that they were going to lose? Was the defection an action designed to thwart the Democratic process? How many times, while Democrats were in control, did they ramrod legislation through the Texas Legislature? 

Now that the shoe is on the other foot, can we truly say Democrats defended Democracy, or are they now “sore losers”? Although innovative, and bold, the Democratic Defection shut the legislature down; they stopped the people’s business. The Democrats are wrong.

Democracy lost. Neither side conducted the people’s business, neither side compromised; neither side took action to do what is best for the people of Texas. The people lost.

The New York Times reported “Redistricting may not be dead yet this year. Gov. Rick Perry, a Republican, could call a special session to address redistricting.” Despite the defection, Democrats back at square one if Govern Perry calls the special session—probably prepared to defect again.

What remains to be seen is whether this defection will prompt compromise—

If it does, Democracy wins. If it does not, the Republicans win.

Stuart James